Wednesday, October 17, 2007

Fixing errors at the sides edges of your knitting

includes 12 illustrations

Have you ever had a terrifying mess like this at the side edge of your knitting?

A mess like this occurs when stitches come loose at the edge and run out. Perhaps a stitch slipped off the needle, perhaps you dropped a stitch near the edge to correct an error and things got out of control. Whichever way it happened, the mess looks scary. A run at the side edge of your knitting creates loops --giant loops--that look nothing like the ladder of an ordinary run.

Most knitters (including, for many years, me) would rather rip back a mess like this--would rather "frog" it--than try to fix this on the needles. However, from now on, the situation is altered. No longer do you need to frog: you can go your way rejoicing. In the same way as you can use a crochet hook to efficiently correct an ordinary run, so you can use a crochet hook to correct a run which occurs at the edge...if you keep your wits about you. Today's TECHknitting will show you how.

In person, the problem looks worse than it actually is: the curl at the edge of most knitted fabrics contributes to the confusion, and the loose loops overlay one another. If you could take away all the curl in the fabric and organize the overlapping loops--if you could lay the mess out neatly--the problem would look like the illustration below. (In this illustration, the three edge stitches have become unmoored, and have run out 6 rows down.)


Below are two different ways to fix this problem, depending on how you created the very edge stitch--the selvedge stitch--when you first created the fabric. Many knitters (myself among them) always run a chain selvedge in the fabric--created by slipping the first (or last) stitch on every row. (For complete instructions on how to create a chain selvedge, click here.) One reason to run a chain selvedge is that it makes correcting errors in the side edges easier. The first set of illustrations below (numbered with pink circles) show how to correct a run when the fabric was originally knitted with such a chain selvedge.

However, not every knitter runs a chain selvedge in their work. If you are a knitter who knits every stitch on every row, it will be slightly more complicated to fix runs at the side edges--it requires you pin the the fabric to a board in order to fix it. However, although more complicated, it is by no means impossible, and the second set of illustrations (numbered with green circles) shows how.

CORRECTING EDGE ERRORS when the fabric has a CHAIN SELVEDGE

1 (below) In this illustration, three edge stitches have run down 6 rows. The 3 edge stitches of the last row NOT to run out are called the "foundation row" and are labeled by color. The very edge stitch is red, the two interior stitches are green and blue.

Due to the chain selvedge, the red stitches will be hooked up in a 1-for-2 pattern--1 edge stitch for every 2 rows. Because 6 rows raveled out, there will be a total of 3 edge stitches to be recreated. The two interior stitches, the green and the blue, will be hooked up in an ordinary 1-for-1 pattern--1 stitch per row. Because 6 rows ran out, 6 total stitches in each column need to be recreated.

2. (below) Begin by hooking up the red edge stitch as shown. Remember that for a chain selvedge, the outer edge of each loop need only be drawn through once.

3. (below) Continue hooking up the red stitches along the outside edge of the loops. As you can see, this process begins to turn the loops into something more closely resembling ordinary ladders in the area above the green and blue stitches.

4. (below) Once the red stitches have all been hooked up and deposited on the needle, begin with the green stitches. Unlike the red stitches, which are chain selvedge stitches--hooked up 1 stitch per 2 rows--the green stitches are ordinary stitches, and are hooked up one stitch per row, as shown.

5. (below) Once the green stitches have been hooked up and deposited on the right knitting needle, hook up the blue stitches in the same manner, as shown.

6. (below) The finished product. Of course, it will not look all neat like this--it will be wonky because the tension has been much disturbed. However, some careful picking at the stitch arms with your knitting needle will adjust the tension better. Wearing and blocking will smooth things out further until, over time, you won't be able to tell there was ever a problem.

CORRECTING EDGE ERRORS when the fabric has an ORDINARY SELVEDGE

1. (below) When you are running an ordinary selvedge, the work of correcting an error at the edge is a little more complex. The trouble arises because the outer edge of each loop must be turned into two stitches--one above the other, to match the fact that every stitch of every row was knitted. Stated otherwise, because the edge stitch was not slipped, you must have the same number of stitches along the edge of the work as in the interior columns. This takes a little hocus-pocus to create, but, with the help of pins and a board, a run on this sort of edge can also be corrected. Begin by pinning out the loops, as shown. Next, draw the "bottom" part of the outermost portion of the loop into the foundation stitch (red) with a crochet hook as shown.

2. (below) Once you have drawn up the part of the loop below the pin, you next draw up the outermost part of the loop above the pin. In other words, the red stitches are hooked up once below the pin and then again another time above the pin. This creates 2 stitches at the outer edge of every red loop.

3 (below) Once the edge stitches have been created, the pins can come out, and the two interior columns (green and blue) are hooked up in the same manner as shown in illustrations 4 and 5 of first series (with pink circles, above). (However, if you find it easier, you need not remove the pins until you have hooked up all the columns.)

4. (below) The finished work. As stated above, the tension will be wonky when the error is first fixed. However, judicious tension readjustment of the stitch arms with a knitting needle, coupled with blocking and wear, will all act together to smooth out the area until no trace of the correction shows.

One last thing: The run-out loops in these illustrations are not to scale. A loop resulting from 5 or 6 raveled out stitches is relatively longer than the illustrations. Paradoxically, once you start hooking up, the ladders are relatively shorter than they appear in these illustrations. You may need to use a very small hook indeed for the interior (green and blue) stitches. However, although the loops are longer in the real world and the ladders shorter, these illustrations give the general idea. Hopefully, this trick will save you having to rip out--to "frog" your work the next time you get run-out stitches at the edge of your fabric.

In the nature of a true confession, I must finish this post by adding that, over time, I myself have come to fix errors in side stitches by working across the rows, instead of in the columns, as illustrated. Sadly, my "along-the-row procedure" is as impossible to explain as it is to illustrate. It consists of muddling first forward, and then backward on each loop in turn--not exactly the sort of neat & tidy step-by-step process suitable for inclusion in a TECHnique blog. Nevertheless, after you've internalized error-correcting along the columns, you might like to experiment for yourself with correcting along the rows. Despite the fact that working in the columns is easier to explain, I believe the tension comes out better when this trick is worked along the rows.

--TECHknitter
((You have been reading TECHknitting on: "Correcting errors at the side edges of your knitting")

23 Comments:

Blogger jennsquared said...

I think I know what you are talking about. I think I do the row thing without knowing that it is a technique, just like magic loop! ah-hem, my gf just corrected me that anything is a technique because there is no wrong way of knitting. :)

Thanks for sharing.

October 17, 2007 7:24 AM  
Blogger Gale said...

Very nice tutorial. Thank you.

October 17, 2007 9:22 AM  
Blogger maitai said...

thank you! i can fix mistakes within a row just fine, but i always wondered how to fix the edge row! i would just always wing it since that edge wouldn't be visible after seaming anyway. but it's nice to know what it's SUPPOSED to look like!

October 17, 2007 9:23 AM  
Anonymous Kim said...

I swear, you're in my brain! As I'm working on a stitch pattern and lamenting about how my k2tog's and my ssk's don't look at all alike...BAM! left leaning decrease tutorials! As I panic about losing rows and rows of edge stitches in a tangled mess...BAM! edge stitch saving tutorial!

ROCKS!

October 17, 2007 9:34 AM  
Blogger errs said...

This was just what I needed! I'm working on a scarf that has a reverse stockinette edge, that I decided was actually garter stitch for three rows. I fixed everythign but the outside stitch. Thanks for making something so scary, so easy!

October 17, 2007 9:49 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thank you. Thank you. thank you. You just saved my first sweater.

October 17, 2007 11:01 AM  
Blogger BeadKnitter said...

Thank you thank you thank you!! This is one of those problems that has had me baffled for years! The pins are a brilliant idea!

October 17, 2007 12:33 PM  
Blogger HennHouse said...

Thank you for today's post, as well as, for providing all the wonderful information on your site. I confess I have been one who would frog to fix an error on the side edge, but next time I'm ready to tackle it--thanks to you!

I also focused in on your link to the tutorial for the chain side selvage. I've been trying to figure out how to do that and find that I have been "twisting" my chain because I had not been knitting into the back loop of the end knit stitch. So I did a swatch your recommended way through the back loop and find that my through the front loop twisted way gives a little bit firmer edge that looks sort of braided--pretty I think--and might still be a good option for a piece that is not going to be seamed.

A question: are there any other ways to do a side selvage other than the chaini selvage?

Many thanks for the wealth of info on your site.

October 17, 2007 1:42 PM  
Blogger --TECHknitter said...

Hi Henhouse: A "plain" (untwisted) chained selvedge is less likely to pull up the fabric, and is far easier to seam up. However, for a scarf or other project which will not be seamed, but which will have exposed edges, you can certainly twist the chain selvedge if you think it looks prettier. The big thing is consistency. An edge of mixed twisted and untwisted chains would be unattractive. As far as other selvedges go, yes, there are others, and someday, I will post about them...
--TECHknitter

October 17, 2007 1:54 PM  
Blogger Mary-Lou said...

Lovely illustrations as always! - and I do the along the row thing too, which is probably much more fiddly :)

October 17, 2007 3:31 PM  
Blogger HennHouse said...

I'll keep watching for your future postings about selvages. Thank you for taking the time to reply to my question.

October 17, 2007 3:32 PM  
Blogger Micki said...

This is the most useful thing I've read all day--thanks!

October 17, 2007 4:35 PM  
Blogger alt.ayu said...

wow! you know i'm always afraid of something like this happening? and then I won't ever know what to do? Now I know where to look! :) Thanks for this tutorial!

October 17, 2007 9:59 PM  
Blogger Digital Leaf said...

ahh, my hero!!!

October 19, 2007 3:45 PM  
Blogger wideblueyarn said...

I've just come accross your site and I LOVE IT!! I was looking for help with laddering down to fix a stitch but found so much more. Thanks! :)

October 22, 2007 4:20 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I can't thank you enough for this post. Never figured out how to begin to fix these. Now I know.

December 12, 2007 9:02 AM  
Anonymous songdeva said...

Thanks for responding so fast on Ravelry with the link to your incredible tutorial. I'm a fan!

February 6, 2008 7:55 PM  
OpenID dailythread said...

Hi! I just found this post while googling for how to pick up a dropped edge stitch. I thought I was going to have to rip 9 rows of a sweater, and right when I was about to hit the underarm, too (it's a top-down raglan). But you saved my sanity! Thanks! (And why do none of the great finishing technique books in my personal library address dropped stitches on the edge? They should!)

May 8, 2008 10:05 PM  
Blogger *Michelle* said...

OMG! Thank you soooo much! Two from one-- exactly the concept I needed to "get it"! This post saved the day. & I was able to fix a mistake in my seed stitch button band!

August 23, 2008 5:48 PM  
Anonymous Colleen Haiber said...

I'm so glad someone documented this particular fix and shared it oneline. Thanks a whole bunch!

September 5, 2008 6:03 PM  
Blogger Jenny said...

thank you :)

November 7, 2008 4:13 PM  
Anonymous amie said...

seems I'm a little late to see this but that's b/c I've never had to fix this before. Anyway, thanks so much. Lovely technique pics saved me from ripping out and maybe from tears!

April 7, 2009 10:51 AM  
Blogger Christine said...

Non-slip stitch edges have always baffled me. Your directions are excellent. But I am wondering, what changes does one make from the above directions if the knitting is in garter stitch? Is it enough to pick up the strand above the pin purl-wise rather than knit-wise, or is there an extra step involved?

June 30, 2009 10:19 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home